Pitchfork told "the story of feminist punk in 33 songs" back in 2016 (which arguably explains some of the later choices, Priests and Downtown Boys among them) but the listicle-dressed-up-as-a-narrative didn't come to my attention until they tweeted about it on International Women's Day.
There are a lot of familiar names: Patti Smith kicks us off, and there are also mentions for X-Ray Spex, The Slits, Bikini Kill, Sleater-Kinney and Le Tigre (represented by the excellent 'Hot Topic'). But I also learned plenty along the way - such as that I may have dismissed The Raincoats prematurely having hated them at an ATP ('No One's Little Girl' has a great bassline and holds a strange fascination), that Huggy Bear were a blast and that PJ Harvey's '50ft Queenie is about pegging. And that's not to mention all of the intriguing bands and artists the article has introduced me to: The Bags, Kleenex/LiLiPUT, Slant 6, Vivien Goldman (I had no idea she made music as well as writing about it - let alone with Adrian Sherwood). Perhaps the biggest revelation is discovering that Crass were capable of sounding like a no-wave Stereolab.
It was great to see the inclusion of Bush Tetras' 'Too Many Creeps', a song that Thurston Moore put on my radar back in 2014. Moore's own band Sonic Youth also feature in the form of 'Flower' - a curious choice, perhaps, given the existence of 'Swimsuit Issue', 'Tunic (Song For Karen)' and 'Pacific Coast Highway', but indisputably great. More controversial, Pitchfork concede, are Hole ('Violet') and Fugazi ('Suggestion') - given that Courtney Love railed against riot grrrl and that Fugazi were, y'know, an all-male band. But Kathleen Hanna's comment rings true: Ian Mackaye's appropriation of a female voice might be problematic, but he nevertheless led the way in demonstrating that women's issues are men's issues too.
Tuesday, April 02, 2019
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment